News

Cast Guide for The Story of Lyle and Erik Menendez

By Andrew Jack

September 25, 2024September 25, 2024

3 minutes, 10 seconds Read

Monsters: The Lyle And Erik Menendez Story – Cast Guide

Monster: The Story of Lyle and Erik Menendez is about the infamous case of two brothers who were convicted of murdering their parents, José and Mary Louise “Kitty” Menendez, in their home. Erik was 18 at the time and Lyle was 22. In 1996, they were found guilty of first-degree murder and sentenced to life in prison without the possibility of parole.

The new series by Ryan Murphy and Ian Brennan revolves around the brutal murders. Here are the actors who portray real people:

Nicholas Alexander Chavez portrays Lyle Menendez (one of the brothers).

He also starred in the television series General Hospital (2021–2024), plays Spencer Cassadine.

Cooper Koch portrays Erik Menendez (one of the brothers).

He also starred in the horror film Swallowed (2022) in the role of Benjamin.

Javier Bardem portrays José Menendez (Erik and Lyle’s father).

He also appeared in the film Mother! (2017), where he played the character Him.

Chloë Sevigny portrays Mary Louise “Kitty” Menendez (Erik and Lyle’s mother).

She also starred in the television series The Girl from Plainville (2022), stars Lynn Roy.

Nathan Lane portrays Dominick Dunne (an investigative journalist).

He also starred in the television series The Gilded Age (2022–2023), plays Ward McAllister.

Ari Graynor portrays Leslie Abramson (criminal defense attorney and chief defense attorney for Erik Menendez).

She also starred in the film For a great time call … (2012), as the character Katie Steel.

Dallas Roberts plays Dr. Jerome Oziel (Erik Menendez's therapist).

He also starred in the television series Insatiable (2018–2019) as the character Bob Armstrong.

Leslie Grossman plays Judalon Smyth (lover of Dr. Jerome Oziel and key witness in the case).

She also appeared in American Horror Story (2017-2024), in which he plays various roles, including Margaret Booth in AHS 1984.

Jason Butler Harner plays Les Zoeller (Beverly Hills Police Department detective and lead investigator in the Menendez case).

He also starred in the television series Ozarks (2017), stars Roy Petty.

Enrique Murciano plays Carlos Baralt (Lyle and Erik's uncle and brother-in-law of Jose Menendez).

He also starred in the television series The Night Agent (2023), in the role of Ben Almora.

Michael Gladis portrays Tim Rutten (Leslie Abramson’s husband).

He also appeared in the television series Death and other details (2024), in the role of Keith Trubitsky.

Drew Powell plays Detective Tom Linehan (detective on the case).

He also appeared in the television series Gotham (2014–2018) in the role of Butch Gilzean/Solomon Grundy.

Charlie Hall portrays Craig Cignarelli (Erik's friend).

He also appeared in the television series Single drunk woman (2022–2023) in the role of Joel.

Gil Ozeri portrays Dr. William Vicary (a psychiatrist).

He was also seen in #BlackAF (2022) as the character Danny.

Jeff Perry portrays Peter Hoffman (Jose's business partner).

He also appeared in the television series scandal (2012–2018) as Cyrus.

Tessa Auberjonois portrays Dr. Laurel Oziel (Jerome's wife).

She also played in How I met your father (2022–2023), plays Naomi.

Tanner Stine portrays Perry Berman (friend of Erik and Lyle and former tennis coach).

He also played in Days of Our Lives – Beyond Salem (2022), plays Joey Johnson.

Larry Clarke portrays Brian Andersen (uncle of Lyle and Erik).

He also appeared in the television series Paragraphs (2021–2023) starring Ted Day.

Jade Pettyjohn plays Jamie Pisarcik (was in a relationship with Lyle and was a tennis pro).

She also starred in the television series Big Sky (2020-2021) as Grace Sullivan.

Marlene Forte portrays Marta Cano (Lyle and Erik's aunt).

She also appeared in the television series The client (2022–2023) in the role of Judge Teresa Medina.

And finally, Paul Adelstein portrays David Conn (prosecutor in the retrial of the Menendez brothers).

He also appeared in Cruel summer (2023) as Steve Chambers.

What do you think of the cast for Monster: The Story of Lyle and Erik Menendez? Let me know in the comments.

Cooper Koch portrays Erik Menendez (one of the brothers).

He also starred in the horror film Swallowed (2022) in the role of Benjamin.

Javier Bardem portrays José Menendez (Erik and Lyle’s father).

He also appeared in the film Mother! (2017), where he played the character Him.

Chloë Sevigny portrays Mary Louise “Kitty” Menendez (Erik and Lyle’s mother).

She also starred in the television series The Girl from Plainville (2022), stars Lynn Roy.

Nathan Lane portrays Dominick Dunne (an investigative journalist).

He also starred in the television series The Gilded Age (2022–2023), plays Ward McAllister.

Ari Graynor portrays Leslie Abramson (criminal defense attorney and chief defense attorney for Erik Menendez).

She also starred in the film For a great time call … (2012), as the character Katie Steel.

Dallas Roberts plays Dr. Jerome Oziel (Erik Menendez's therapist).

He also starred in the television series Insatiable (2018–2019) as the character Bob Armstrong.

Leslie Grossman plays Judalon Smyth (lover of Dr. Jerome Oziel and key witness in the case).

She also appeared in American Horror Story (2017-2024), in which he plays various roles, including Margaret Booth in AHS 1984.

Jason Butler Harner plays Les Zoeller (Beverly Hills Police Department detective and lead investigator in the Menendez case).

He also starred in the television series Ozarks (2017), stars Roy Petty.

Enrique Murciano plays Carlos Baralt (Lyle and Erik's uncle and brother-in-law of Jose Menendez).

He also starred in the television series The Night Agent (2023), in the role of Ben Almora.

Michael Gladis portrays Tim Rutten (Leslie Abramson’s husband).

He also appeared in the television series Death and other details (2024), in the role of Keith Trubitsky.

Drew Powell plays Detective Tom Linehan (detective on the case).

He also appeared in the television series Gotham (2014–2018) in the role of Butch Gilzean/Solomon Grundy.

Charlie Hall portrays Craig Cignarelli (Erik's friend).

He also appeared in the television series Single drunk woman (2022–2023) in the role of Joel.

Gil Ozeri portrays Dr. William Vicary (a psychiatrist).

He was also seen in #BlackAF (2022) as the character Danny.

Jeff Perry portrays Peter Hoffman (Jose's business partner).

He also appeared in the television series scandal (2012–2018) as Cyrus.

Tessa Auberjonois portrays Dr. Laurel Oziel (Jerome's wife).

She also played in How I met your father (2022–2023), plays Naomi.

Tanner Stine portrays Perry Berman (friend of Erik and Lyle and former tennis coach).

He also played in Days of Our Lives – Beyond Salem (2022), plays Joey Johnson.

Larry Clarke portrays Brian Andersen (uncle of Lyle and Erik).

He also appeared in the television series Paragraphs (2021–2023) starring Ted Day.

Jade Pettyjohn plays Jamie Pisarcik (was in a relationship with Lyle and was a tennis pro).

She also starred in the television series Big Sky (2020-2021) as Grace Sullivan.

Marlene Forte portrays Marta Cano (Lyle and Erik's aunt).

She also appeared in the television series The client (2022–2023) in the role of Judge Teresa Medina.

And finally, Paul Adelstein portrays David Conn (prosecutor in the retrial of the Menendez brothers).

He also appeared in Cruel summer (2023) as Steve Chambers.

What do you think of the cast for Monster: The Story of Lyle and Erik Menendez? Let me know in the comments.

Similar Posts

Leave a Reply Cancel reply